Political interference and weak oversight continue to cripple policing across all levels of government, warns expert

Independent researcher and Institute for Security Studies (ISS) consultant David Bruce says political interference in policing is an entrenched problem in South Africa, extending from national to local government levels.

Speaking in response to testimony from General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi at the ad hoc police inquiry, Bruce said such interference often influences operational decisions, including how public order policing is deployed during protests.

He argued that while the Constitution gives the Minister of Police authority to set national policing policy, this responsibility has been neglected for over two decades.

Bruce suggested that meaningful reform should focus on clarifying command structures and ensuring stronger coordination between the SAPS and metropolitan police forces.

However, he cautioned that any devolution of policing powers must be balanced against risks of corruption and mismanagement at provincial and municipal levels.

Reflecting on the ongoing Madlanga Commission of Inquiry, Bruce noted that commissions often shed light on systemicissues, but rarely lead to lasting change unless there is political will to act.

"Basically, these commissions, their value is in providing a greater level of scrutiny and transparency. Quite often, they can be seen as providing an opportunity, if there is that kind of political initiative to take advantage of that opportunity. For instance, respond to the policy questions that have been raised. But you know, the policy-making responsibility of the minister is, you could say, completely neglected for something like 25 years."

To listen to David Bruce in conversation with CapeTalk and 702's Mandy Wiener, click the audio below: