Analysis: Blatter quit as pressure rapidly built from all sides
After 17 years at Fifa, the world’s biggest football body’s president Sepp Blatter has called it quits.
LONDON - "Who got him? Who shot him? What happened between then and now?" asked the English Football Association's chairman Greg Dyke, a former TV executive as he pondered the downfall of Sepp Blatter, who announced his resignation as Fifa president on Tuesday.
Others may have put the questions in a less colourful way but they were still the main ones on everyone's lips.
As parts of the football world celebrated his departure, many could only ask how a man who last Friday was seen clasping his hands together and crying "Let's go Fifa!" after his re-election to the top job at the sport's governing body was now to be found surrendering quietly.
The contrasting image was now of 79-year-old Blatter being ushered off stage towards a back-door exit after a short resignation speech in Zurich, looking suddenly very fragile.
Scores took to twitter to express their delight following this announcement:
Sepp Blatter May 29th, 2015 - "I am the President of everybody"— Faizal Khamisa (@SNFaizalKhamisa) June 2, 2015
Sepp Blatter, June 2, 2015 - I am no longer President
So Sepp Blatter resigned from FIFA. I heard it was so he could run a #boxing sanctioning body!!!!!!!!!— Dan Rafael (@danrafaelespn) June 2, 2015
Whatever happens to Sepp Blatter am available for FIFA Presidency #SeppBlatterResigns— RSA Min of Sport (@MbalulaFikile) June 2, 2015
When I heard Sepp Blatter resigned pic.twitter.com/FgLVBx112Q— Temporary Giants Fan (@BasedChasen) June 2, 2015
Blatter wasn't sole responsible, more have to follow. Transparency and voting reform, then we move on and bring back ethics. #FIFA— Vincent Kompany (@VincentKompany) June 2, 2015
After all, this was Blatter we were talking about, widely known as the most able sports mover and shaker of his time. A modern-day Houdini who had won many skirmishes with opponents was never expected to depart so quietly.
So what did happen? What got Blatter to recognise so suddenly his time was up? Was it because FBI agents have just too much information about dubious payments involving Fifa officials to easily shake off their questions?
Or was it just the understanding of a wise old politician who recognised that the squeeze being applied by everyone from disgruntled sponsors to unhappy former football stars would lead to suffocation of his hopes for Fifa sooner rather than later.
In his departure announcement, Blatter sought to explain that his resignation was a noble gesture to help the game he loved, and there were plenty of his allies, and some foes, who were happy to play along with the narrative.
Michel Platini, the head of European football, who had urged Blatter to go last week, praised him for making "a difficult decision, a brave decision, and the right decision" while Jerome Champagne, a potential candidate to take over the job, admired his "sacrifice" to help Fifa.
Some of his delighted critics though, were not prepared to pull their punches.
"I don't believe he went on any sort of moral basis because I don't believe that's the man," said Dyke, a former TV executive. "I just don't think he's the sort of person who would suddenly have had a moral conversion on the road to Damascus and said, 'Oh maybe I'm not the right person for football'. He would have hung on forever so clearly something has happened."
Like what? A source close to Fifa told Reuters that in the wake of all the opprobrium heaped on the organization since last week's arrests of Fifa officials, pressure had been put on Blatter by officials on the executive committee and people in his inner circle to go.
Blatter was apparently told by the advisers who he has always listened to, even if he has often ignored their suggestions, that if he wanted to choose when and in what manner he would depart, he should do so now.
By doing so, he could point to the massive growth that Fifa has achieved during his 17-year reign, the successes in developing football across the world, and the advance of the game among women and youth.
For once, the source said, Blatter did what he was told.
Pressure from key Fifa sponsors behind the scenes may also have played an important part.
There was no great public outpouring of indignation from them after Friday's Blatter victory but Coca-Cola Co.'s declaration after Blatter's resignation speech on Tuesday gave an inkling of how some companies really felt.
"The announcement today is a positive step for the good of sport, football and its fans ... and will help Fifa transform itself rapidly into a much-needed 21st century structure and institution," said Coke.
Adidas, another major sponsor, welcomed Blatter's resignation. "Today's news marks a step in the right direction on Fifa's path to establish and follow transparent compliance standards in everything they do," Adidas said.
Blatter's removal appeared to be what many stakeholders wanted. "Problem solved. This was the major hurdle and changes everything," said Andrew Woodward, a sports marketing consultant who was former director of public relations for Visa.
Ultimately, though, the fact that the US investigations into Fifa had begun to get ominously close may have persuaded him to depart now.
Reuters and other news media reported on Monday that US authorities believe that Fifa Secretary General Jerome Valcke made $10 million in bank transactions related to the award to South Africa of the rights to hold the 2010 World Cup. Reuters sourced the report to a person familiar with the matter.
Valcke is described in an indictment filed in federal court in Brooklyn, New York, as an unidentified "high-ranking Fifa official" who in 2008 transferred the sum to another Fifa official, Jack Warner.
Fifa claimed Valcke was not involved but a letter addressed to the Frenchman, sent by the South African Football Association president Molefi Oliphant ahead of the 2010 World Cup, added to the questions.
Some saw the investigation's focus on Valcke as crucial in Blatter's departure. Per Ravn Omdal, former president of the Norwegian Football Association, who served on the Fifa executive from 1994 until 2002 and had a close first-hand working relationship with Blatter in the early years of his reign, said he believes this was critical.
Omdal told Reuters: "I'm sure the letter from the South Africa FA was the tipping point. It was to his own general secretary who had denied it. It was getting too close."
Late on Tuesday, a source who spoke on condition of anonymity told Reuters that Blatter himself is being investigated by US prosecutors and the FBI. Fifa and Blatter could not be immediately reached for comment.
Blatter has been accused of many things by his critics, yet he has never been so out of touch as not to recognise when the whole deck has been stacked against him.
"I do not feel that I have a mandate from the entire world of football, the fans, the players, the clubs, the people who live, breathe and love football," he said in his departure announcement.