-
Experts label Mboweni’s Budget speech ‘too optimistic’
Business -
[LSITEN] Private hospital in Soweto launches new cardiac centre
Business -
Mrwebi denies ever being in cahoots with Selebi
Local -
Lawyer seeks to ditch Vicki Momberg
Local -
Police on standby in Diepsloot amid reports of fresh protests
Local -
#RandReport: Rand flat after slipping in knee-jerk reaction to budget
Business
Popular Topics
-
[CARTOON] A Low Ebb
Business -
'No free lunch here': Treasury to closely monitor SOEs that get bailouts
Business -
Treasury ready to defend Budget in meeting with rating agencies
Business -
IAAF's case against Semenya not in good taste - Sonke Gender Justice
Local -
#JasonRohde: Defence argues crime committed in a moment of passion, weakness
Local -
Slain Ngcobo policemen to be remembered one year after police station attack
Local
Popular Topics
-
Mboweni's gesture of goodwill: No pay hike for MPs
Politics -
[WATCH] 'Extremely flat & no plan on SOEs' – MPs slam Mboweni’s Budget speech
Politics -
Spend less time criticising national govt, Zille told in Sopa debate
Politics -
PSC finds Muthambi broke some rules when hiring staff at private office
Local -
IEC hoping for 80% turnout in May elections
Local -
2,000 unplaced learners in attendance as WC opposition debates Zille's Sopa
Local
Popular Topics
-
[OPINION] We could drink a case of Caster
Opinion -
[OPINION] Both democracy & authoritarianism are on the rise in Africa
Opinion -
[OPINION] Abolition of Angola’s anti-gay laws may pave way for regional reform
Opinion -
[OPINION] Load shedding 101 - a Zimbabwean's survival tips for SA
Opinion -
[OPINION] What mapping Kenya’s child deaths for 50 years revealed
Opinion -
[OPINION] Of spoofs, gaffes and the #MensConference
Opinion
Popular Topics
[CARTOON] A Low Ebb
-
'No free lunch here': Treasury to closely monitor SOEs that get bailouts
Business -
Treasury ready to defend Budget in meeting with rating agencies
Business -
Economists not impressed with Mboweni's maiden Budget speech
Business -
Standard Bank to testify at Zondo Commission about suspicious SOE transactions
Business -
'You want money from us, we'll put you under curatorship,' Mboweni warns SABC
Business -
Mboweni: 'Eskom’s turnaround can’t be allowed to fail'
Business
Popular Topics
-
Chicago police charge Jussie Smollett with filing false report of assault
Lifestyle -
Designer Karl Lagerfeld to be cremated without ceremony
Lifestyle -
Jackman enters Guinness Book of Records for longest-serving Marvel superhero
Lifestyle -
50 Cent left ‘fearing for his life’ in wake of alleged police threat
Lifestyle -
Jack Whitehall to perform with Hugh Jackman at BRITs
Lifestyle -
Dolly Parton praises #MeToo movement
Lifestyle -
Beyoncé and Jay Z ban guests from taking photos at pre-Oscars party
Lifestyle -
Budget breaker: Ithuba confirms R232m PowerBall winner from Cape Town
Lifestyle -
Did Khloe Kardashian confirm Tristan Thompson cheating rumours?
Lifestyle
-
IAAF's case against Semenya not in good taste - Sonke Gender Justice
Local -
Formidable Atletico stun Ronaldo and Juventus
Sport -
England post record chase to beat Windies in series opener
Sport -
Daniels delighted, Jele unhappy as SuperSport sink Pirates
Sport -
Spurs star Kane back in training ahead of schedule
Sport -
Xasa confirms facilitator to oversee Sascoc changes
Sport
Popular Topics
-
[WATCH] #Budget2019 in 60 seconds with Bruce Whitfield
Business -
[WATCH] Taxi driver caught transporting 46 kids in vehicle
Local -
[WATCH] Failed launch of UKZN's sounding rocket seen as learning opportunity
Local -
[WATCH] Cosatu marches on Parly ahead of Budget speech
Local -
[WATCH] Tuks host Maties in pick of Varsity Cup fixtures
Sport -
[WATCH] DA kicks off mobilisation week ahead of manifesto launch
Politics -
[WATCH] How did we get here? The Eskom crisis explained
Business -
[WATCH] Xasa: 'The IAAF is being sexist towards Caster Semenya'
Sport -
[WATCH] Disruptions and protests as Zille delivers her final Sopa
Politics
-
[LISTEN] Banking Association of SA urges calm over Eskom restructuring
Business -
[LISTEN] Are teachers ill-equipped to control classrooms?
Local -
[LISTEN] SAA says not unbundling, but changing business model
Business -
[LISTEN] What SA tax laws say about churches & religious institutions
Business -
[LISTEN] PAC accepts SACP’s Solly Mapaila’s apology for Sobukwe statement
Politics -
[LISTEN] Here's how to prevent students from dropping out
Lifestyle -
[LISTEN] It's about Time! SA artist Nelson Makamo on magazine cover triumph
Lifestyle -
[LISTEN] Unbundling Eskom a step in the right direction?
Business -
[LISTEN] Khoisan heritage still marginalised, says expert
Local
[CARTOON] Budget Meals
-
[CARTOON] We're with you, Caster!
Sport -
[CARTOON] No Love Lost
Politics -
[CARTOON] PerSONA non grata
Politics -
[CARTOON] Two-Faced Malema
Politics -
[CARTOON] Agrizzi 'Fesses Up
Local -
[CARTOON] Fat Cats 'n Rats
Politics -
[CARTOON] RIPTuku
Africa -
[CARTOON] Spanners in the Works
Politics -
[CARTOON] Not One To Blow His Own Trumpet...
Politics
- Thu
- 28°C
- 15°C
- Fri
- 27°C
- 15°C
- Sat
- 28°C
- 14°C
- Sun
- 31°C
- 15°C
- Mon
- 29°C
- 13°C
- Tue
- 30°C
- 15°C
- Thu
- 23°C
- 17°C
- Fri
- 30°C
- 17°C
- Sat
- 25°C
- 17°C
- Sun
- 26°C
- 16°C
- Mon
- 23°C
- 15°C
- Tue
- 21°C
- 15°C
- Thu
- 30°C
- 16°C
- Fri
- 29°C
- 16°C
- Sat
- 29°C
- 15°C
- Sun
- 33°C
- 17°C
- Mon
- 32°C
- 16°C
- Tue
- 30°C
- 17°C
- Thu
- 30°C
- 14°C
- Fri
- 29°C
- 16°C
- Sat
- 30°C
- 15°C
- Sun
- 32°C
- 16°C
- Mon
- 31°C
- 15°C
- Tue
- 32°C
- 16°C
- Thu
- 27°C
- 23°C
- Fri
- 26°C
- 22°C
- Sat
- 29°C
- 22°C
- Sun
- 28°C
- 22°C
- Mon
- 27°C
- 23°C
- Tue
- 31°C
- 22°C
- Thu
- 22°C
- 18°C
- Fri
- 23°C
- 18°C
- Sat
- 22°C
- 18°C
- Sun
- 23°C
- 18°C
- Mon
- 22°C
- 16°C
- Tue
- 22°C
- 16°C
- Thu
- 33°C
- 17°C
- Fri
- 35°C
- 19°C
- Sat
- 29°C
- 18°C
- Sun
- 31°C
- 18°C
- Mon
- 30°C
- 17°C
- Tue
- 21°C
- 13°C
- Thu
- 26°C
- 17°C
- Fri
- 27°C
- 18°C
- Sat
- 24°C
- 18°C
- Sun
- 23°C
- 17°C
- Mon
- 23°C
- 16°C
- Tue
- 19°C
- 15°C
- Thu
- 33°C
- 15°C
- Fri
- 31°C
- 18°C
- Sat
- 32°C
- 17°C
- Sun
- 36°C
- 19°C
- Mon
- 35°C
- 17°C
- Tue
- 34°C
- 18°C
- Thu
- 32°C
- 12°C
- Fri
- 33°C
- 16°C
- Sat
- 35°C
- 17°C
- Sun
- 34°C
- 15°C
- Mon
- 31°C
- 16°C
- Tue
- 32°C
- 16°C
- Thu
- 27°C
- 15°C
- Fri
- 26°C
- 18°C
- Sat
- 27°C
- 16°C
- Sun
- 29°C
- 16°C
- Mon
- 27°C
- 17°C
- Tue
- 29°C
- 15°C
- Thu
- 23°C
- 18°C
- Fri
- 24°C
- 17°C
- Sat
- 23°C
- 17°C
- Sun
- 23°C
- 16°C
- Mon
- 25°C
- 16°C
- Tue
- 22°C
- 14°C
ANC's Mangaung winner may lack legitimacy
Whoever is elected leader of the African National Congress (ANC) at its conference next month may suffer from a lack of legitimacy, with implications for the long-term future of the party.
This is because last week ANC Veterans League chairman Sandi Sejake publicly claimed there had been manipulation of branch numbers within the ANC.
He suggested that unless serious steps were taken, the leadership elected during the party's Mangaung conference would lack legitimacy.
On the same day, reports emerged claiming that a group of armed men had burst into an ANC branch meeting in Ekurhuleni in Gauteng and forced party members present to vote to nominate President Jacob Zuma.
Also, perceptions of the fairness of Luthuli House, the party's head office, appear to be open to question, with those who stand to lose out at Mangaung appearing to be prepared to make claims, even if they cannot make them stand up.
Sejake's claims appear to bolster the arguments of those who have suggested that the number of branches in KwaZulu-Natal has been inflated to strengthen Zuma's chances. Sejake's position, his seniority, and the fact he is making the claims in public could all serve to start a debate within the ANC about the numbers.
The alleged attack in Ekurhuleni also leads to suspicions Zuma's supporters are prepared to resort to violence. As this occurs amid claims that he is using the Umkhonto we Sizwe Military Veterans Association as a private army, the claims could gain some currency.
The association has denied the suggestions but has issued several statements that could be interpreted as threatening to Zuma's opponents.
Many ANC branches appear to be battling to reach quorums at branch general meetings, held to nominate leaders.
All of these factors, when taken together, could point to problems around legitimacy for Zuma, should he be re-elected.
At the same time, several ANC leaders, particularly his rival, Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe, have spoken out against the use of "slates", the practice where ANC leaders run for positions as a group. However, at this stage it appears whoever wins at Mangaung will probably have used a slate, thus further de-legitimising themselves.
This means that when certain disputes within the party have to be resolved after the conference, Zuma could appear to lack the moral and political authority to intervene.
As the ANC appears to grow in membership and finds consensus harder to attain, these disputes could become more common. At the same time, they will become harder to resolve because he and other elected leaders would find it hard to create long-term solutions to problems and could only have the legitimacy to create short-term solutions.
One of the more important moments of Zuma's first term as ANC leader occurred a few months into his presidency, when the Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) said it believed he had been elected through an alliance of forces that opposed former president Thabo Mbeki. This was a public admission that the ANC had not elected him as the best possible candidate, but because only he was seen as able to dislodge Mr Mbeki.
That moment was key, as it showed Cosatu did not support Zuma for himself but only for what he had stood against. This made it harder for him to appear to be the legitimate leader of the party. Should he be re-elected, he could well face the same problem again.
However, he and other leaders could re-establish their legitimacy if the task teams investigating the manipulation claims are seen to be able to reach accurate findings. Should Zuma publicly disavow "slates" and be seen to win on his own strengths, that could re-establish his credibility.
This column appeared in The Business Day.
More in Opinion
-
[OPINION] The life-changing Laureus Sports awards
20 hours ago -
[OPINION] We could drink a case of Caster
one day ago -
[OPINION] Both democracy & authoritarianism are on the rise in Africa
one day ago -
[OPINION] Abolition of Angola’s anti-gay laws may pave way for regional reform
3 days ago -
[OPINION] Load shedding 101 - a Zimbabwean's survival tips for SA
3 days ago -
[OPINION] What mapping Kenya’s child deaths for 50 years revealed
4 days ago
Choose an EWN Twitter account
Follow @ewnreporterFollow @ewnupdates
Follow @ewnsport
Follow @ewntraffic
Comments
EWN welcomes all comments that are constructive, contribute to discussions in a meaningful manner and take stories forward.
comments powered by DisqusHowever, we will NOT condone the following:
- Racism (including offensive comments based on ethnicity and nationality)
- Sexism
- Homophobia
- Religious intolerance
- Cyber bullying
- Hate speech
- Derogatory language
- Comments inciting violence.
We ask that your comments remain relevant to the articles they appear on and do not include general banter or conversation as this dilutes the effectiveness of the comments section.
We strive to make the EWN community a safe and welcoming space for all.
EWN reserves the right to: 1) remove any comments that do not follow the above guidelines; and, 2) ban users who repeatedly infringe the rules.
Should you find any comments upsetting or offensive you can also flag them and we will assess it against our guidelines.
EWN is constantly reviewing its comments policy in order to create an environment conducive to constructive conversations.